Blog

Uncategorized

Division 2 State Finals Projections

WEEK THREE
WEEK FOUR
CHAMPIONSHIP SEASON
COUNTY WEEK
LEAGUE WEEK
REGIONAL WEEK

This year’s version of the State Projections and Previews will be lighter on the writing than the previous ones. There’s a reason that I wrote so much for the rankings throughout the year, hopefully you can refer back to those for the backstories on the teams and individuals.

This year, just as the regionals were last week and projections were last year, I worked with the simulations. I liked my regional write-up for that, here’s one for example if you’d like to read. For the State version, I ran through 10x more simulations. Which really doesn’t sound like much, but when you graduate from 1,000 simulations to 10,000, that’s a significant jump. And given that the projected state qualifying teams were higher than ever, perhaps we’re onto something.

Girls Team Projections

Projected Place Ranges

Projected Scores by Runner

Analysis

This is about as straight-forward as you’ll get. Grand Rapids Christian has been dominant in every meet, whether that’s placing four in the top-8 at Otsego and Region 11, winning Portage, or beating Pioneer at Benzie. For second, it’s likely a two horse race between Otsego and Goodrich. It’s very tough coming back as the defending champ, but the Bulldogs have handled it admirably. Goodrich is seeing the realization of all that middle school talent that’s flown into their program these past few years. Goodrich is probably a bit stronger towards the back, though Otsego has three potential All-Staters, meaning they only really have to worry about scoring two.

Girls Individual Projections

Projected PlaceGradeNameTeamAvg. Place
112Natalie VanOtterenGR Christian1.8
212Gail VaikutisSt. Joseph3.0
311Elena FigueroaSt. Joseph3.5
49Ava SchaferSt. Johns5.0
512Emily TomesGR Catholic Central6.1
612Drew MullerEast Grand Rapids7.0
711Emma DrnekZeeland East8.8
810Katie BerkshireGaylord9.9
912Mary RichmondFrankenmuth10.8
1010Ellie ScholmaGR Christian11.5
1112Meghan FordMason14.4
1211Sadey SeyferthEast Grand Rapids14.8
1310Lilah PoelGR Christian15.3
1411Kamryn LauingerGoodrich15.4
1510Emma HoffmanOtsego15.5
1612Logan BrazeeOtsego15.6
1711Ezgi KurtAlma21.7
1812Jenna PilachowskiMonroe Jefferson22.6
1911Summer BrowerLudington23.1
2011Sophy SkeelsAdrian23.7
2112Payton HoltzGR Christian24.4
2212Megan GermainOtsego24.5
2311Natalia DeMeaChelsea24.8
2412Allison KuzmaZeeland East25.6
2512Addison WashlerFHE Ada Forest Hills Eastern29.9
269Clara KaczorFreeland30.1
2712Kyla MeyersSpring Lake31.6
289Olivia HollebeekHolland Christian32.9
2912Naomi NelsonGR Christian33.6
3012Emma DeVriesGR West Mich. Aviation33.8
3112Camille DeColaMarshall33.9
3211Ava CrewsMiddleville Thornapple-Kellogg35.3
3311Layla JordanGoodrich35.9
3410Natalie FoltzFrankenmuth37.5
3510Samantha BrownClio37.7
369Caroline RandallHastings38.3
3712Anastee DavisAdrian38.5
3812Nora O’LearyPetoskey40.6
3911Kayla WilliamsDeWitt41.0
4012Tatum DykstraFruitport41.3
4112Abby YoungSt. Johns41.3
4212Ellia AgarGR_South Christian45.3
4311Eva ThompsonCroswell-Lexington46.3
449Eliana StobHolland Christian47.4
459Ayda SkeelsAdrian48.7
469Adeline ArmstrongEast Grand Rapids49.0
479Lucy ConzelmannFrankenmuth49.9
4811Mea D’AgostinoOrchard Lake St. Mary’s51.6
4912Bea ReeserSpring Lake51.8
509Jaelyn RayPinckney52.1
519Baylor LauingerGoodrich52.6
5210Brooklynn BrownCadillac54.9
5312Maddie BoschHudsonville Unity Christian55.7
549Annabelle LowmanLudington55.9
559Kylie MausolfBirch Run56.0
5610Linnea PaigeFremont56.5
5710Berkley HoltzSturgis57.9
5811Madison MorrisTecumseh58.4
5912Emma SteeleVicksburg64.4
609Ellery LampenHolland Christian65.6
6111Joy EvansAlma66.3
6211Madison JohnsonPaw Paw66.9
6311Chloe JosephsonLinden68.4
6410Alexis KotkowiczSpring Lake69.5
6510Chloe KhonJackson Northwest71.3
6611Preslee PerkinsStevensville Lakeshore71.8
6712Ava BaltierraArmada72.6
6811Maria NunningPontiac Notre Dame Prep73.2
6912Adia SikkemaGR Christian74.5
7010Taryn DiLauraZeeland East75.5
7112Sparrow CentenoSouthgate Anderson77.2
7212Claire MarosiGR Catholic Central77.8
739Lucy WaalkesGR Christian78.2
7412Clara FletcherSt. Johns78.5
7512CamBrie CoreyPetoskey81.7
7610Meredith CookZeeland East81.7
779Claire BrownGoodrich81.9
7812Morgan NewtonCroswell-Lexington81.9
799Mia MaySparta81.9
8011Taylor MitchellOtsego82.3
8110Avery TurkNew Boston Huron82.5
8211Cami KraaiWhitehall83.1
8310Ava PawlickPetoskey88.0
8411Karie KeeferFreeland88.3
8511Nicole SchaferWilliamston88.4
8611Avery ByrneGoodrich89.3
879Lane IsomRichland Gull Lake90.1
8812Jennifer Hernandez-MedinaThree Rivers91.3
8910Emma CrandellOwosso91.7
9010Jillian ClasonFHE Ada Forest Hills Eastern92.5
919Melody MeckstrothLinden92.8
9211Josie JenkinsonOwosso93.6
9312Libby SummerlandOwosso95.7
949Sophia SchaferWilliamston96.8
9510Miriam KlohaSt. Johns97.5
969Skylar MejeurOtsego98.1
9711Courtney BovairCarleton Airport98.4
9810Josie LongcorePlainwell98.9
9910Falyn DossNew Boston Huron99.0
10012Jade MurdochSt. Joseph102.3

It’ll probably be these three girls at the front. They’ve all shown the ability to ratchet things down into the mid-17’s when needed, such as their matchups at Cougar Falcon and Portage. Gail Vaikutis captured Portage, Natalie VanOtteren at Cougar Falcon, and Elena Figueroa was right there in each. The ratings slightly favor VanOtteren, but the ratings aren’t the greatest at taking those who are saving their energy, as it appears the St. Joseph tandem has been doing the past few weeks. Beyond these three, look for freshman Ava Schafer, defending champ Drew Muller, and Emily Tomes to kick down any carnage that presents itself.

Boys Team Projections

Projected Place Ranges

Projected Scores by Runner

Analysis

You’re just gonna have to read Jacob Tanner’s excellent, lengthy preview. I told Jacob before the week that I wasn’t going to work on the same subjects that he did and he knocked it out of the park here. Real quick though, it all depends on where the packs are. If there’s a ton of runners between FHE/Allendale/GR Christian’s 4th and 5th and Pinckney’s 4th and 5th, the former will likely stay ahead. If not, Pinckney has a real chance. If so, it comes down to the first three guys of those first three teams, and as of now, it appears that FHE has the strength there.

Boys Individual Projections

Projected PlaceGradeNameTeamAvg. Place
112Connell AlfordChelsea2.0
211TJ HansenFreeland2.4
312Evan LoughridgePinckney2.8
412Solomon KwartowitzCranbrook Kingswood4.3
512Alex TholeEast Grand Rapids6.4
611Jack BidwellMarshall7.5
712Noah LambersHolland9.2
812Paul MoorePinckney9.3
911Colin MurrayDearborn Divine Child12.3
1011Henry DixonForest Hills Eastern12.7
1112Nate CarmodyHaslett13.8
1212Sean PettisFremont13.9
1312Braylon PettyAdrian15.3
1410Ronnie SilveiraAllendale17.8
1511Simon TriezenbergGR Christian18.9
1612Ryan BrinkerEast Grand Rapids20.8
1712Logan RuffnerRiverview20.8
1812Elliott SirianniClio21.0
1912Brendan HovingForest Hills Eastern24.0
2012Liam HinmanForest Hills Eastern24.9
2110Thomas LarsonAlma25.8
2212Gregory JanesakSparta26.3
2310Jonah WorkmanEast Grand Rapids26.5
2411Dominic LowrieBC Harper Creek26.5
2510Owen MetzgerSparta26.6
2612Nolan PinionLake Fenton27.2
2711Alex DonethMason27.3
2811Dylan LydicHaslett29.2
2912Ethan SandulaPinckney29.7
3011Will EngbersHolland Christian30.7
3111Kilian WhalenAllendale31.6
3212Caleb PalmreuterGladwin32.2
339Ezekiel BaltierraAlma34.3
3410Moises SalazarAdrian35.5
3512David MurphyFlint Powers Catholic40.1
3612Aiden KruegerNiles40.5
3712Isaac StaibSt. Johns41.3
3812Brewer SnayMacomb Lutheran North41.8
3911Seth MeadGladwin42.3
4011Abatu DykstraHamilton43.1
419Bryce CahoonShepherd43.9
4211Nolan LonguskiShepherd44.1
4311Henry CoxPlainwell44.5
4411Parker TiethofAllendale45.0
4511Jeb HillaryGR Catholic Central47.0
4612Cooper JacobsenForest Hills Eastern47.2
4712Shay WhiteSt. Joseph47.7
4812Connor GriffithMarshall49.4
4912Andrew YaxClio50.5
5011Nolan InglisDeWitt50.6
5112Shane IzzardPetoskey50.7
5212Nolan NixonCadillac51.0
5312Dylan ClarkGR Christian51.3
5411Caleb WesseldykOtsego55.4
5510Brett MagnusFrankenmuth55.9
5611Keegan HoekstraGR Christian56.9
5711Elijah ChristensenGladwin58.2
5810Edison LopemanParma Western58.5
5911Stewart WatersWhitehall61.8
6011Ben GrossAllendale62.2
6111Sullivan ZietlowThree Rivers65.4
6212Blake FergusonYale65.9
6312Luke GlasgowSpring Lake66.0
6410Bryce GrossFlint Powers Catholic66.9
6512Cooper SingletonParma Western67.1
6612Giovanni Pardo-KeeganYale67.1
6712Jacob MontgomeryIonia69.7
6811Carter ShermanFremont74.6
6911Landen WiseFrankenmuth75.2
7012Ali KudmaniAlma76.8
7111Jack LillywhiteFlint Kearsley78.2
7211Owen SaylorDowagiac Union78.3
7312Matthew SchraubenSt. Johns78.9
749Ryan GoodParma Western79.5
7512Jonathan KoetjeGR Christian80.9
7612Tommy FarleyPetoskey81.6
7712Ian RichthammerGR Catholic Central85.0
7811Jacob HopkinsDetroit Country Day85.0
7911Reece DavisMarshall85.2
8011Isaak RubleyDundee85.4
8112Acer CampbellYale85.7
8212Tate MillerForest Hills Eastern86.1
8310Vincent PattisonGoodrich86.2
8412Isaac VeenPlainwell87.4
8510Murphy WagnerSaginaw Swan Valley87.7
8612Peter KuperusGR Christian88.1
8712Dane BaileyEdwardsburg88.7
8812William O’DellBC Harper Creek88.8
899Mason HillAllendale90.0
9010Kenny ShefferOtsego91.2
9111Cougar ClarkFrankenmuth93.7
9212Matthew CanalesAdrian95.3
9310Micah SmallGR Christian95.9
9410Jack EdisonEast Grand Rapids96.6
9512Joe WaalkesGR Christian97.6
9611Aidan GoodwinOtsego97.7
9711Will WhitmoreHolland Christian98.3
9811Dylan PallettWayland Union98.4
999Abraham McHughMarshall98.5
10012Dylan DistelrathSt. Clair100.6

The odds have Connell Alford as the slight favorite. Those odds don’t take into account that he’s won here before, which in my opinion plays a bit of a role. But he hasn’t won here before with this level of competition. Results this year show that he can – whether that’s low-15’s at Portage and Spartan or a dominant win in his opener at Lamplighter. TJ Hansen probably has the most pop, highest wow factor of any competitor. Those who were at Bluejay say that he looked completely under control during his negative-splitted 14:46. Following a defeat at Portage, he’s cruised into the meet here, can he now summon that effort from a month ago? Evan Loughridge has been the most consistent of the bunch, steadily running the equivalent of 15:20’s each time out. One of those times was a win over Alford, another a win over Kwartowitz. Solomon Kwartowitz has the fastest 3200m PB of the bunch and his resume this season consists of hills, hills, and more hills. MIS should appear like a pancake compared to this past month, so there’s a great chance he outperforms his ranking just like last year.

Uncategorized

Division 3 State Finals Projections

WEEK THREE
WEEK FOUR
CHAMPIONSHIP SEASON
COUNTY WEEK
LEAGUE WEEK
REGIONAL WEEK

This year’s version of the State Projections and Previews will be lighter on the writing than the previous ones. There’s a reason that I wrote so much for the rankings throughout the year, hopefully you can refer back to those for the backstories on the teams and individuals.

This year, just as the regionals were last week and projections were last year, I worked with the simulations. I liked my regional write-up for that, here’s one for example if you’d like to read. For the State version, I ran through 10x more simulations. Which really doesn’t sound like much, but when you graduate from 1,000 simulations to 10,000, that’s a significant jump. And given that the projected state qualifying teams were higher than ever, perhaps we’re onto something.

Girls Team Projections

Projected Place Ranges

This is something new. I’ve always had odds for winning or placing, but I never thought to give odds for each place. Hopefully this will better show the range of places for each team and better elucidate teams that are more consistent and those who have a slight propensity for the chance at a major day.

Place and Score by Runner

Analysis

The Division 4 Preview had a little look into whether the Fastest Fifth Theory is true. Essentially, the idea goes that if you have the first fifth finisher, you have the best chance at winning a State Meet. I’ve had it told to me that every D1 girls winner at MIS has had the fastest fifth in the field, I wondered if that was the case for all divisions. This is only going back to 2019, with the technology these days, it’s a quick look. Prior to 2019, it’s a slower look, but definitely ripe for off-season inspection.

What I can glean from this data is that having the first fifth finisher is important, but not 100% necessary to win. If you have four elite runners such as Hart’s girls from 2019-2021 or Otsego’s girls last year, you can build up enough of a gap to overcome a pack finishing before your final scorer. If you don’t have those elite four, your 5th runner better be within 20 seconds of the fastest 5th in the field, or else you’re accumulating too many points in a hurry.

For Division 3’s girls, there’s five teams that could come in before anyone else: Lumen Christi, Traverse City St. Francis, GR Covenant Christian, and Elk Rapids. With that said, the race may be won by firepower up front. Each team has a potential All-Stater, some have two, some even have three. As the race unfolds, I might look more at who is coming in early, as each of these teams have the depth late.

Another one of my theories, one that’s completely untested and I’m not even sure how I’d research, is that teams that move up throughout the race tend to do better in big race environments. Maybe I’m influenced by the MSU Women, who have won consecutive Big Ten titles using this strategy. But it makes sense, in that teams that are fading are giving away places and teams that are moving up are usually running even/negative splits and catching people. My assumption is that teams that score lower and lower points with each mile are less apt to get too excited and amped up in the moment.

Spartan
Holly
Bluejay
Portage

There have been some common races between the bunch. At Shepherd, the only team missing was Lumen Christi. At Portage, the only team missing was Elk Rapids. Lumen Christi won Portage by placing all five girls in the top-30, St. Francis won at Bluejay with the same array of places. The Elk girls mastered moving up throughout the Bluejay race, scoring 140 at the mile and 92 at the finish. If conditions favor heavy amounts of places being exchanged late, don’t be shocked if the ER girls move into the top-3.

Girls Individual Projections

Projected PlaceGradeNameTeamAvg. Place
111Jessica JazwinskiHart1.1
212Madison OsterbergJackson Lumen Christi2.3
311Kyah HoffmanStanton Central Montcalm3.4
411Emmry RossOnsted3.9
511Betsy SkendzelTraverse City St. Francis6.3
612Tessa RoeLansing Catholic6.7
711Lila VolkersKent City7.3
812Mylie KellyBenzie Central7.9
911Eliza BushYpsilanti Arbor Preparatory8.7
1012Miranda McNeilMorley-Stanwood8.7
119Samantha SchroederJackson Lumen Christi12.9
1212Amber KooleGR Covenant Christian13.0
1311Whitney WernerPewamo-Westphalia13.0
149Kamryn SalladayLakeview16.2
1512Jenna SweeneyReese19.8
1611Ashley ChoponisStanton Central Montcalm21.9
1710Brynne SchulteElk Rapids23.9
1812Liliana LehnstIthaca24.1
1912Kinsie JacquesPinconning25.2
2012Olivia PerrineHanover-Horton25.4
2111Kaya VrableCaro25.7
229Isabelle SliterFennville27.1
2310Hope MillerBlissfield27.2
2410Grace CostonStanton Central Montcalm27.9
259Sophia BuzzelliClare28.0
2612Cylee ElkinsClinton28.5
279Shelby KuiperGR Covenant Christian28.6
2812Isabella MaxKent City29.1
2912Jaiden DickmanSt. Louis30.0
3010Bella LaFountainMonroe St. Mary CC30.1
3112Cecilia PostmaManistee31.1
3212Avelina HollandsworthRemus Chippewa Hills32.3
3311Nora GrossnickleBenzie Central32.5
3412Gracie HoutmanKent City34.9
3510Macy FazekasJackson Lumen Christi36.2
3611Mary MasserantTraverse City St. Francis36.2
3710Ashlynn HarrisBronson36.8
3811Lola BryceGrandville Calvin Christian38.3
3911Ava HathawayBronson38.7
4012Paige HerronCaro38.8
419Molly Kate HollandsworthTraverse City St. Francis39.0
4211Megan WoelkersFlat Rock42.3
4310Quinn HatfieldRemus Chippewa Hills47.5
4412Allison BowlesClinton48.1
4512Sophia ReynoldsHanover-Horton49.5
4610Anna PrayElk Rapids49.6
4712Claire NeumannSaginaw Valley Lutheran49.9
4811Alaina KloosterKalamazoo Christian50.2
4912Maddie GallagherTraverse City St. Francis50.2
5011Isabelle EppertFarwell51.3
5110Myleigh HephnerIthaca54.5
5211Lexie Beth NienhuisHart54.7
5311Layla LopezJackson Lumen Christi55.2
549Alyssa KramerPewamo-Westphalia57.9
559Makinna FoglesongIthaca58.7
569Libby SchusterAnn Arbor Greenhills59.1
579Lydia SoelbergShelby61.4
5810Mattie GagneMidland Bullock Creek61.6
5912Abbie WiegersNorth Muskegon63.1
6011Chloe StalhoodHillsdale63.5
6110Frances MelinnLansing Catholic63.7
629Alli GautscheUnion City64.9
639Reagan LeesWixom St. Catherine64.9
6412Angel MillerParchment65.0
6512Melanie WernerPewamo-Westphalia65.6
6611Hunter ShellenbargerElk Rapids67.3
6712Nidia MartinezFennville70.6
689Pyper BraunEPBP Laker71.2
6912Sydney FazekasJackson Lumen Christi72.3
7010Hailey CreisherLeslie74.3
7110Abbie SchneiderPewamo-Westphalia75.8
7211Erin LubahnLeslie77.6
7312Tessa WohlschlegelBeaverton78.5
7410Hailey SillsBlissfield78.8
759Lydia MinderhoudGR Covenant Christian78.9
7611Emma MillerBuchanan81.0
7710Anna PoppemaBath81.4
7812Emily AngerMancelona82.3
7912Faith SwenorCaro83.4
8012Lindsay MinderhoudGR Covenant Christian84.5
8112Jaida SchulteElk Rapids84.9
829Grace WonchLansing Catholic85.0
8310Sarah TrojanowskiTraverse City St. Francis85.7
849Anna DeVriesGR Covenant Christian87.7
8512Morgan LowellWatervliet88.0
8611Hannah GeaneyWyoming Potter’s House88.4
879Marnath TuolGrandville Calvin Christian88.6
8812Eva PrayElk Rapids90.0
8910Kandin ShulerBridgman93.6
9010Delaney LittleBoyne City94.3
9112Olivea GessnerOlivet95.1
9211Clara FastBridgman95.2
939Natalie RosemaHart95.3
949Jenna KeilenPewamo-Westphalia96.1
9511Madeline YoungBuchanan96.7
9611Emily RathkaLaingsburg97.3
9712Rachael WalchCaro97.6
9812Samantha CootsClinton98.0
9912Anika BeryAnn Arbor Greenhills98.2
10011Ariana PillotSchoolcraft99.3

Jessica Jazwinski is clearly the favorite coming in here and for good reason, when she’s on her game, she races with extreme toughness. The problem for others in that previous sentence is that she’s almost always on her game, especially at the longer distances. She’s rattled off low-17 efforts each time this year when put to the test – whether that’s Bluejay, Cougar Falcon, or at Chippewa Hills.

There seem to be three that have separated themselves beyond Jazwinski. Madison Osterberg has added strength to her impressive mid-distance resume. The D3 winner in the 1600m, she’s taken where she left off from last year’s MITCA race and has raced to a multitude of sub-18’s. She’s done it on fast courses and in the mud at Hudson Mills. Emmry Ross (your defending D3 400/800m champ) had some mid-season battles with Osterberg and Kaylie Livingston, pushing to a 17:29 personal best at Stockbridge. Kyah Hoffman has lost when facing Osterberg or Ross, but has the most consistency of the bunch, dipping below 18:00 on occasion and hitting the equivalent of low-18 marks each time out.

Boys Team Projections

Projected Place Ranges

Place and Score by Runner

Analysis

Traverse City St. Francis is clearly the favorite. The Gladiators have it all, the GladPack in the middle, low sticks up front. They won by significant margins at the mid-season, state preview meets such as Bluejay or Portage, scoring seven boys before many teams’ 4th or even 3rd.

What’s wide open is the race for the other podium spot, the other trophy. Reed City may have languished behind some of these folks at Bluejay and may have the weakest depth, but the Yotes collectively had the best race of their season at Region 20, adding up to only 20 points while bringing all five boys home before 18-flat. Covenant Christian and Pewamo-Westphalia have more depth than Reed City and have shown the ability to pass in droves late. And Hanover-Horton has the tradition of always outperforming these numbers. The Comets are projected 5th here, that’s almost a guarantee they’ll be at least 3rd.

Boys Individual Projections

Projected PlaceGradeNameTeamAvg. Place
19Robert Jazwinski IIIHart1.9
212Collin FarmerPewamo-Westphalia2.5
311Isaiah DinvernoJackson Lumen Christi5.5
412Ben MarchSt. Louis7.8
512Samuel MartiniKent City9.5
612Keegan MastersOttawa Lake-Whiteford9.8
710Gage HoffmanStanton Central Montcalm10.0
812Brad WhiteClare10.4
911Mitchell HiattOnsted11.1
1011August RohdeReed City11.8
1111Theodore DavisDansville12.2
1212Jackson RodriguezWyoming Potter’s House12.5
1312Boden GenoveseColoma13.3
1411Leo SwagerTraverse City St. Francis14.3
1510Jacob StanislawskiFlat Rock15.4
1611Landon PestrueSt. Louis15.4
1712Anthony KiaunisReed City16.6
1812Lucas HopkinsOlivet18.9
1911Levi KampsGR Covenant Christian21.2
2012Jaden BarnesBloomingdale22.1
2111Josh SlocumTraverse City St. Francis23.0
2212Ryan AllenReed City23.8
2312Gavin GuggemosKalkaska24.4
2412Graham CostonStanton Central Montcalm24.6
2510Landen StykaIthaca24.7
2611Tyler HealSanford-Meridian27.4
2711Landen BoulisHanover-Horton28.2
289Graeson DeckerGR Covenant Christian29.5
2911Daniel MandujanoWatervliet31.1
3012Evan ShepherdHanover-Horton33.0
3112Gavin VanKampenJonesville35.0
3211Isaac EdgingtonHolland Black River38.0
3310Ben GautscheUnion City38.9
3412Brodie DelamaterGrant39.9
3512Tucker KrummTraverse City St. Francis40.3
3612Nolan GrantHillsdale41.9
3712Nathan DaySaranac42.3
3812Carter HolmesBath43.6
3912Gannon ShoreJackson Lumen Christi43.6
4010Lucas TaraszkiewiczFlat Rock44.8
419Caleb BlondeJonesville45.7
429Hunter EatonCharlevoix46.6
4311Nathan VargoFlat Rock46.9
4412Trevor DornbosGrandville Calvin Christian47.0
4510Robert DykhouseManton47.7
4612Andrew KlausClare48.6
4710Noah DevereauxLaingsburg49.2
4811Owen ReadTraverse City St. Francis49.7
4911Robby MylerTraverse City St. Francis51.1
5010Sylus WilsonStanton Central Montcalm52.0
5112Alex CzeiszpergerHudson55.3
5211Lewis WalterTraverse City St. Francis56.2
5312Bailey WigginsMidland Bullock Creek56.8
5410Qwynn DarnellElk Rapids59.4
5512Ezra HagedornWyoming Potter’s House61.0
569Wyatt WernerPewamo-Westphalia61.2
5711Riley PattinsonTraverse City St. Francis61.7
5811Luke DykstraGR Covenant Christian62.4
599Cole HillegondsClinton62.8
609Jonas BallardHolland Black River62.8
6111Allan GeorgePewamo-Westphalia64.7
6211Cade TruemnerEPBP Laker64.7
6311Miingen BertrandIthaca64.8
6411Brayden SweeneyMidland Bullock Creek65.6
6512Drew MooreGrayling67.2
6611Dante PillotSchoolcraft67.6
6712Hunter HelminskiSaranac69.3
6812Anthony UrbaniakCharyl Stockwell Academy70.9
6912Conner FountainOlivet72.5
7010Grant JohnsonManchester72.8
7112Lincoln ChaAnn Arbor Greenhills73.7
7211Tristan DemlowGrayling73.9
739Luke HerronCaro74.1
7410Julian WalkerAlgonac75.8
7511Andrew MabryBridgman77.4
7612Nic PorterClare78.6
7710Tyler LeachOtisville LakeVille79.9
7810John EdlerHomer80.0
7911Ian WaddellBlissfield80.5
8011Luke SkidmoreBath81.4
8110Zach HassenzahlHanover-Horton84.7
829River FoxBath86.9
8312Andrew KoenigsknechtBath87.2
8411Clay PowellOvid-Elsie88.0
8511Gabe ManchesterClinton88.7
8611Austin SulierErie Mason90.5
8711Sam MuirheadPewamo-Westphalia90.8
8810Nicholas FowlerJonesville92.8
8912Grant KooleGR Covenant Christian93.5
909John KowatchPewamo-Westphalia93.6
9112Lucas GoodmanClinton94.4
9210Jack SlotmanHart97.1
9311Parker CampbellErie Mason97.2
9410Gibson ShoreJackson Lumen Christi97.4
9510Jayden FoxSaginaw Valley Lutheran102.1
9611Max StittHart102.4
9712Adam WilliamsKalkaska102.9
9812Owen BrownHanover-Horton103.3
9912Tanner SoelbergShelby104.2
10012Noah FintonWyoming Potter’s House105.1

When June came and passed, I (and maybe many) wondered if there’d ever be another Hunter Jones. Well, we didn’t have to wait long for the answer, as Bobby Jazwinski is putting up the same kind of numbers that Hunter did as a freshman. Opening with a 15:48 at Benzie, continuing to multiple 15:3x efforts and even faster. Of course, when anyone freshman bursts onto the scene, there are seniors looking to hold them off, and Collin Farmer has done the best of the bunch. Head-to-head, Farmer has won, with a narrow victory at Bluejay, then a significant margin at Portage. This begs the question that the ratings attempt to capture: were those two matchups an example of the differing speeds of the two or was it a combination of Jazwinski having poor races/Farmer having great races? We’ll find out on Saturday.

Uncategorized

Division 4 State Finals Projections

WEEK THREE
WEEK FOUR
CHAMPIONSHIP SEASON
COUNTY WEEK
LEAGUE WEEK
REGIONAL WEEK

This year’s version of the State Projections and Previews will be lighter on the writing than the previous ones. There’s a reason that I wrote so much for the rankings throughout the year, hopefully you can refer back to those for the backstories on the teams and individuals.

This year, just as the regionals were last week and projections were last year, I worked with the simulations. I liked my regional write-up for that, here’s one for example if you’d like to read. For the State version, I ran through 10x more simulations. Which really doesn’t sound like much, but when you graduate from 1,000 simulations to 10,000, that’s a significant jump. And given that the projected state qualifying teams were higher than ever, perhaps we’re onto something.

Girls Team Projections

Projected Place Ranges

This is something new. I’ve always had odds for winning or placing, but I never thought to give odds for each place. Hopefully this will better show the range of places for each team and better elucidate teams that are more consistent and those who have a slight propensity for the chance at a major day.

Place and Score by Runner

Analysis

Many charts and sheets, here’s the last one:

A little look into whether the Fastest Fifth Theory is true. Essentially, the idea goes that if you have the first fifth finisher, you have the best chance at winning a State Meet. I’ve had it told to me that every D1 girls winner at MIS has had the fastest fifth in the field, I wondered if that was the case for all divisions. This is only going back to 2019, with the technology these days, it’s a quick look. Prior to 2019, it’s a slower look, but definitely ripe for off-season inspection.

What I can glean from this data is that having the first fifth finisher is important, but not 100% necessary to win. If you have four elite runners such as Hart’s girls from 2019-2021 or Otsego’s girls last year, you can build up enough of a gap to overcome a pack finishing before your final scorer. If you don’t have those elite four, your 5th runner better be within 20 seconds of the fastest 5th in the field, or else you’re accumulating too many points in a hurry.

This fall, it appears that Whitmore Lake won’t have the first fifth runner in the field, that might apply to Western Mich. Christian. In the same range also is Johannesburg-Lewiston, their final scorers projected within 11 points of one another. The three teams faced off at Portage, with Johannesburg taking home a trophy, placing four girls in the top-14, putting forth enough of a gap to weather the WMC pack. Whitmore Lake was a bit behind J-L, there with WMC through four, but their final scorer finished a minute back of where she’s been crossing the line these past few weeks.

Each team has an argument:

Whitmore Lake – the improved racing of their 3rd-5th girls (Meadows, Robertson, Weaver) over the past few weeks.
Johannesburg-Lewiston – the defending champs, can’t discount championship experience.
Western Mich. Christian – the ability to throw five in front of your four, six in front of your five.

Another one of my theories, one that’s completely untested and I’m not even sure how I’d research, is that teams that move up throughout the race tend to do better in big race environments. Maybe I’m influenced by the MSU Women, who have won consecutive Big Ten titles using this strategy. But it makes sense, in that teams that are fading are giving away places and teams that are moving up are usually running even/negative splits and catching people. My assumption is that teams that score lower and lower points with each mile are less apt to get too excited and amped up in the moment.

Spartan
Holly
Bluejay
Portage

At Portage, teams such as J-L and WMC moved up throughout the race, as did Hillsdale Academy and Mt. Pleasant Sacred Heart. Perhaps the latter two are sleepers to run above their pay grade?

Girls Individual Projections

PlaceGradeNameTeamAverage Place
19Kaylie LivingstonWhitmore Lake1.4
212Aiden HarrandBuckley1.8
311Grace VanderKooiMuskegon Western Mich. Christian3.1
412Ava TeedAllen Park Cabrini5.0
511Allie NowakJohannesburg-Lewiston5.1
69Libby SmithGobles6.6
710Carina BurchiWhitmore Lake7.1
811Izzy BrooksAdrian Lenawee Christian8.1
911Jane MantheiPetoskey St. Michael10.2
1011Eliza KeithAuburn Hills Oakland Christian11.6
1112Brooke SmithPittsford13.7
129Stefi ReskevicsHarbor Springs14.2
1311Ella KnudsenLeland15.4
1412Miriam MurrellGaylord St. Mary15.8
1510Taylor WiegandLivingston Christian16.1
169Veyda ConleyMartin20.3
1710Sofia RobertsonWhitmore Lake20.4
1811Juniper RodhamHarbor Springs20.9
1912Natalie MeadowsWhitmore Lake22.4
2012Madalyn AgrenJohannesburg-Lewiston23.7
219Harlie FoxJohannesburg-Lewiston23.7
229Haley StimerConcord24.9
2312Allison GlendeningSt. Joseph Our Lady of the Lake Catholic25.1
249Ava DeYoungGobles26.9
2512Isabella YeomanGenesee27.5
2611Abigail DavisVestaburg27.6
2710Ally SchmitzBreckenridge31.4
289Lauren ShafferGobles32.3
299Lyvia CurtisSaugatuck32.6
3010Lilah KileyKingston34.7
3111Presley AllenMendon36.3
3212Eleanor KingshottMuskegon Western Mich. Christian36.6
339Leah SnellerMuskegon Western Mich. Christian36.8
3410Yolanda GaschoJohannesburg-Lewiston37.3
359Anna SheppardMt. Pleasant Sacred Heart38.1
369Kamryn SixberrySaugatuck39.9
3712Grace FolkemaMuskegon Western Mich. Christian40.1
389Avery LangloisRogers City41.9
3911Ella WaltonHillsdale Academy42.6
4011Stephanie HernandezAddison44.5
4112Lily LemanskiMarlette46.3
4210Ruth BrownleeHillsdale Academy46.3
439Addy ZellerBear Lake-Onekama46.4
4411Ava MallarPittsford47.3
459Nolee LeppertBeal City48.3
4610Madi HarePlymouth Christian Academy48.6
4712Jacqueline MortonMt. Pleasant Sacred Heart49.0
4810Eleanor ColeLutheran HS Westland50.2
4911Natalie GibbsBirmingham Roeper50.7
5010Cieara BarrettConcord51.3
519Gabriella SiemsKalamazoo Hackett53.1
529Kaylie RiksenMuskegon Western Mich. Christian53.3
5311Riley McCumberPittsford55.0
5410Katie SweeneyUbly56.4
5512Leah ZarrilliAuburn Hills Oakland Christian57.0
5612Alberta ReinboldUnionville-Sebewaing58.0
5711Danica AldrichBreckenridge60.4
5812Ellayna MeredithPortland St. Patrick61.4
5910Brooklynn FrazeeBuckley62.5
6010Emma RikerKalamazoo Hackett64.1
619Elizabeth FurmanIndian River Inland Lakes65.5
6211Kelcie PungFowler67.2
6312Gracy WalkerKingston67.9
6411Reece WrubleHarbor Beach69.7
6510Kinsey PeerBuckley70.0
669Claire LongSaginaw Nouvel71.0
6710Rowan AllenMendon71.6
6811Caroline RobertsHillsdale Academy72.5
6910Lauren NiedzielskiMason County Eastern73.9
709Addison PatrzikGrand Traverse Academy76.9
719Adrienne MitchellLansing Christian77.0
7210Abby BrownleeHillsdale Academy78.1
7310Elodie WeaverWhitmore Lake78.7
7410Madison CooleyGobles78.7
7512Anna McQuearySaugatuck79.4
7612Paige BellGrand Traverse Academy79.8
7712Andrea FeldpauschWhite Cloud80.3
7810Fran WarrenHarbor Springs80.8
7911Brielle VoorheesTri-unity Christian81.2
809Veronica PagaPetoskey St. Michael82.3
819Danielle AgrenJohannesburg-Lewiston87.2
8211Lucy ShoupMason County Eastern88.1
8311Avery WestallBreckenridge88.8
8410Addison ChownykFrankfort89.8
8511Aubrey ApplemanBritton Deerfield90.2
869Mikayla KulawiakBuckley90.8
8711Kyra BeemerBrown City92.3
8811Julia RogersKimball New Life Christian93.1
8911Sarah GoodwinAuburn Hills Oakland Christian94.6
9011Leilani SchoonmakerSaugatuck95.5
9112Zoe Van RijnKingston95.7
929Natalie BurpeeLeland96.5
9311Nataly VineBreckenridge96.6
949Allie MillerHillsdale Academy97.9
9510Cara PrusakiewiczDryden98.4
9610Shenoah CollierGrand Traverse Academy99.9
9711Morgan LawrenceMuskegon Western Mich. Christian100.6
9812Abby KunkleLibertas Christian101.5
9911Erica WalkerClarkston Everest Collegiate102.2
10011Meeghan FlikkieKingston102.3

The one race between these two wasn’t particularly close, with Kaylie Livingston sticking to her guns, asserting her presence early and never letting up. The issue with doing these ratings for an entire season is that experienced seniors know when to pick and choose their battles. My guess is that Aiden Harrand has truly gone all-out a few times this year, once at Portage, then also at Shepherd and Benzie. Her times and ratings from those two meets lead me to believe that she’ll give Kaylie everything she can handle. And from there it can go either way. This will likely be one of the closer individual races on the day, so get out to the Speedway early.

Boys Team Projections

Projected Place Ranges

Place and Score by Runner

Analysis

Judging by the fastest five and moving up through the race, along with their season long ranks and projections, Hillsdale Academy looks to be a strong favorite. Portage is always a great simulation of what a State Finals may entail. Similar competition, similar excitement, and a great number of ranked teams are there in the lower divisions. There, the Colts moved from 2nd place at the mile to 1st at the finish, dropping 35 points along the way. Their fifth was in before anyone’s fourth and they had the frontrunners score low early on.

Beyond them, this is as about as wide-open a race for the 2nd spot as you’ll find. The simulations show four separate teams with a decent percentage of getting there – Saugatuck, J-L, Holland Calvary Christian, and WMC. Three of those faced off in the same region on Saturday, with HCC decidedly dominating up front. Portage again was home to all of these, and when Joburg was thrown into the mix, the Cardinals came out ahead. Saugatuck’s fifth was the best of the bunch, and WMC was the last of the the four (though they beat the Trailblazers on Saturday). So yep, up for grabs by anyone. Don’t even be shocked if a Three Oaks River Valley or Kalamazoo Hackett slides in there.

Boys Individual Projections

Projected PlaceGradeNameTeamAvg. Place
112Owen PattonVestaburg1.1
212Thomas HolmHillsdale Academy4.2
310Abenezer CeroneRoyal Oak Shrine4.7
412Tyler LennMarine City Cardinal Mooney5.8
511Mason SinkeBear Lake-Onekama6.5
610Marek ButkiewiczKalamazoo Hackett9.0
712Abe VanDuinenPentwater10.0
89Kyle RedmanMesick10.2
911Colebrook SutherlandMaple City Glen Lake12.6
1012Malaki GaschoJohannesburg-Lewiston13.0
1111Matthias MorseMuskegon Western Mich. Christian13.3
129Ty RedmanMesick13.3
1312Michael AllenEast Jackson13.5
1412Sawyer StonemanBreckenridge14.1
1510Grayson RorickHillsdale Academy14.3
1611Alex TyndallMason County Eastern15.4
1712Gavin SehyKalamazoo Hackett16.5
1811Reece PooleHillsdale Academy19.7
1912Kaden ForwardBear Lake-Onekama20.3
2010Landon RogersThree Oaks River Valley20.5
2111Jeremiah WittJohannesburg-Lewiston20.7
2212Blake FoxJohannesburg-Lewiston23.3
2310Brody KargHarbor Beach23.7
2411Tyler LaansmaTri-unity Christian28.4
2512Javin MericleEast Jackson29.4
2610Lynus CadarettePetoskey St. Michael29.6
2710Cody BradleyPetoskey St. Michael30.9
289Sawyer MonroeSaugatuck31.5
2912Graeson LawrenceMuskegon Western Mich. Christian32.1
309Riley WeedHolland Calvary Christian32.2
3110Sammy GamboaSaugatuck32.3
3210Landen LivingstonWhitmore Lake34.9
3312Aiden FitchettDryden35.5
3411Coleson CruzanWhite Cloud35.8
359Anthony RoweBreckenridge39.2
3612Austin YorkThree Oaks River Valley40.3
378Lincoln LaansmaTri-unity Christian40.7
389Noah SchipperHolland Calvary Christian41.2
3912Mitchel DanielsPentwater43.0
4012Myles TilmaByron Center Zion Christian43.1
419Gibson WhiteHolland Calvary Christian45.5
4210Emmanuel MehariPlymouth Christian Academy45.7
4310Carson BurgessBrown City46.8
4410Rich FantiRiverview Gabriel Richard47.3
4512Luke SpragueSt Philip Catholic Central47.8
4610Sean SiemsKalamazoo Hackett50.4
4710Carter ClarkCarson City-Crystal50.4
4812Isaac ZammitMarine City Cardinal Mooney50.9
4912Utah GusaUbly52.9
5010Charlie GibsonThree Oaks River Valley58.2
5111Joel LangeAdrian Lenawee Christian58.9
529Marcus SilvaSaugatuck59.2
539Christian GetzHolland Calvary Christian59.3
5410Joel JohnsonDetroit Frederick Douglass59.7
5511Rodney IamurriSaginaw Nouvel59.9
5612Luke NiedzielskiMason County Eastern60.7
579Vern ClyneAuburn Hills Oakland Christian60.8
589Wesley ChaffeeMt. Pleasant Sacred Heart62.7
5911Carroll RobothamFrankfort64.0
6011Matthew PasiakHarbor Beach64.1
619Abraham FeeneyMaple City Glen Lake64.5
6212Carson FoondleWhite Cloud65.9
6312Trevor ClarkeHarbor Springs66.0
6410Cole UpperLincoln-Alcona67.2
6512Connor RouseGenesee68.2
6612Evan SumnerPlymouth Christian Academy70.2
6710Jesse FielisWhite Pigeon71.4
6811Turlough BennettMarlette71.5
6911Russell VandermusPetoskey St. Michael71.8
7010Brennan NorSaugatuck74.3
7110Michael BowkerRoyal Oak Shrine74.3
7212Jacob LyonnaisMuskegon Catholic Central74.4
7312Gavin HelgesonMayville76.1
7412Carter FollettMerrill77.2
7510Henry LindleyHillsdale Academy78.1
7612Logan KihnkeHarbor Springs80.1
7710Adam FergusonHarbor Springs81.0
7811Tom ShaferLutheran HS Westland81.5
7912William KennedyEast Jackson84.1
8010Andrew LopezRoyal Oak Shrine84.3
8112Nathan DanielsAdrian Lenawee Christian85.0
8210Kristian CoonCarson City-Crystal86.1
8312Ben GuraKimball New Life Christian87.6
8411Austin SneedEast Jordan88.0
8511Henry MalburgMason County Eastern88.4
869Ryan MillerHillsdale Academy90.3
8711Zack BeckerUnionville-Sebewaing90.6
8812Agustin CreamerLeland91.1
8911Ben IobeMendon92.8
9012Trevor FeldpauschFowler94.3
9110James RaheHillsdale Academy94.5
9211Samuel ShattoHarbor Beach95.2
9312Dusty LaymanJohannesburg-Lewiston95.6
9412Carter UpperLincoln-Alcona95.7
959Grant RehkopfSaugatuck96.1
969Milo ShoupMason County Eastern96.1
9712Luke DouglasAuburn Hills Oakland Christian96.4
989Landon WilkinsMorenci96.7
9910Cole BregeRogers City97.6
10011Beau ShafferMorenci97.9

Owen Patton is a pretty clear favorite and he’s got a season’s full of results to prove it. He’s run fast early and late, winning along the way as well. A summer of consistent mileage has proven to us and himself that he’s much more than an 800m runner. Thomas Holm has been very consistent all year. Abenezer Cerone has won a large invite in Holly, running away from the D4 field early and maintaining (heck, building) the lead as the race wore on. Tyler Lenn has been battling all year in his return from injury, but we know from past experience that he shows up in big spots.